Funny, creepy, smart ladies

About the show

Dallas based comedians and friends, Christie Wallace and Heather McKinney, focus on a different true crime, cult, or creepy topic each week "and chat all things sinister in this funny and well-researched podcast." (Marie Claire, 2020)

Sinisterhood on social media


  • Episode 88: The Montauk Project

    March 4th, 2020  |  Season 1  |  1 hr 24 mins
    conspiracy theories, government secrets, mind control, the montauk project, time travel

    For decades, true believers have insisted that the government knows more than it lets on about aliens, time travel and mind control. Proof may lie deep under the lush green grass of this Long Island location, where the government conducted experiments that tore through the fabric of space-time and inspired the plot of the hit Netflix show Stranger Things.

  • Episode 87: Aaron Hernandez: Part 4

    February 26th, 2020  |  Season 1  |  1 hr 46 mins
    aaron hernandez, cte, nfl, true crime

    After a superstar defense secured an acquittal and his prior conviction sat awaiting appeal, things seemed to be looking up for the fallen Patriots star. But less than a week after the jury returned the good news, a prison guard would make a devastating discovery. What could have caused Aaron Hernandez's irreversible decision - was it drugs, depression, long term brain damage? And did his death mean he had finally cleared his name?

  • Episode 86: Aaron Hernandez: Part 3

    February 19th, 2020  |  Season 1  |  1 hr 51 mins
    aaron hernandez, true crime

    On the run from one man he tried to kill, a star football player turns to the most powerful person he knows for help - the head coach of the New England Patriots. But after his team turns its back on him, he is first arrested for one crime, then charged with two more. Evidence piles up, multiple trials ensue, and a botched investigation leaves room for questions.

  • Episode 85: Aaron Hernandez: Part 2

    February 12th, 2020  |  Season 1  |  1 hr 29 mins
    aaron hernandez, true crime

    A troubled boyhood. Teen years fueled by drugs and booze. A promising professional football career in danger of being derailed by addiction. And just when it seemed like Aaron Hernandez's dreams were coming true, he is linked to unimaginable acts of violence.

  • Episode 84: Aaron Hernandez: Part 1

    February 5th, 2020  |  Season 1  |  1 hr 7 mins
    aaron hernandez, true crime

    A superstar football player. A beloved son and brother. A violent end. In part one of our three-part series, we discuss Aaron Hernandez's abusive childhood, struggles with his sexual identity, and other forces that could have derailed the promising career of an unstoppable professional athlete, eventually turning him to a life of crime.

  • Episode 83: Pazuzu Algarad and the Meat Warlock

    January 29th, 2020  |  Season 1  |  55 mins 42 secs
    north carolina meat warlock, pazuzu algarad, satanic cult, true crime

    A small North Carolina town was already on edge from a series of gruesome murders when the unthinkable happened - they were visited by a cloaked and mysterious figure tossing out raw meat at a nearby playground. Was it a visit from another self-proclaimed satanist with violent intentions or something more whimsical?

  • Episode 82: The Betz Mystery Sphere

    January 22nd, 2020  |  Season 1  |  1 hr 7 mins
    betz mystery sphere, conspiracy theory, extraterrestrial, paranormal, ufo

    A family moves to an idyllic area of coastal Florida seeking a peaceful life. On a walk, their lives are turned upside down by a seemingly innocent discovery in a patch of grass. Were they the recipients of an object from outer space or did this family misconstrue their treasure as more than what it truly was?

  • Episode 81: Ethan Couch: Affluenza Teen

    January 15th, 2020  |  Season 1  |  1 hr 59 mins
    affluenza teen, ethan couch, true crime

    Luxury cars, large homes, extravagant vacations. Money can buy you a lot of things but can it make you sick? One psychologist has suggested that money doesn’t buy happiness, but instead buys a lack of culpability. In this infuriating case was this a legitimate defense or just another example of the favorable treatment of the rich in our justice system?

  • Episode 80: The Mandela Effect

    January 8th, 2020  |  Season 1  |  1 hr 33 mins
    alternate realities, false memories, the mandela effect

    Some things we swear we remember exactly. A movie quote. The name of a book. The death of a celebrity. But then we find out - we were wrong. Is this revelation the correction of some false memory, the result of glitches in our brains, or are we flip-flopping between dimensions and alternate realities?

    *This episode contains spoilers for the movie The Mandela Effect

  • Episode 79: Y2K

    December 31st, 2019  |  Season 1  |  1 hr 22 mins
    millennium bug, y2k, year 2000 bug

    20 years ago on New Year's Eve, the world held its breath as the clock ticked down towards midnight. Planes falling from the sky. Bank accounts drain to zero. Traffic lights gone dark. The turning of the century called for chaos and confusion. But what happened was more akin to an average, everyday glitch. Was this really the tale of the government who cried wolf or was the United States closer to the brink that we all thought?

  • Krampus (Re-release)

    December 25th, 2019  |  Season 1  |  52 mins 33 secs
    christmas monsters, krampus

    This week we are bringing you a holiday classic from the archives - Krampus! Merry Christmas, Happy New Year, and be good or Krampus will get you!

  • Killer Clowns (Re-release)

    December 18th, 2019  |  Season 1  |  1 hr 5 mins
    coulrophobia, killer clowns

    This week, we are bringing you an archival episode about Killer Clowns. We originally decided to record this topic to give ourselves a break after our three-part series on Ted Bundy. The episode is more funny than scary, and includes a clown fight in the woods that still cracks us up! Happy Holidays!