Funny, creepy, smart ladies

About the show

Dallas based comedians and friends, Christie Wallace and Heather McKinney, focus on a different true crime, cult, or creepy topic each week "and chat all things sinister in this funny and well-researched podcast." (Marie Claire, 2020)

Sinisterhood on social media


  • Episode 21: The Cleveland Strangler

    October 24th, 2018  |  Season 1  |  1 hr 15 mins
    anthony sowell, cleveland strangler, serial killer, true crime

    This is one House of Horrors you do NOT want to visit on Halloween.

  • Episode 20: The Lost Girls of Panama

    October 16th, 2018  |  Season 1  |  59 mins 34 secs
    lost girls of panama, true crime, unsolved mystery

    Was this a hiking trip gone terribly wrong or is something much more sinister to blame?

  • Hear No Evil, See No Evil, Speak Some Evil: Dallas Psychic Fair

    October 10th, 2018  |  Season 1  |  26 mins 44 secs
    astrology, clairvoyant, dallas psychic fair, minisode, numerology, psychic, spirit guides, tarot

    We recount our mind blowing experiences from the Dallas Psychic Fair

  • Episode 19: The Smurl Family Haunting

    October 9th, 2018  |  Season 1  |  1 hr 8 mins
    demon, demonic infestation, ed and lorraine warren, haunting, paranormal, possession, the smurl family

    Was this family's home infested by a demonic presence or was it all an elaborate hoax for fame and fortune?

  • Episode 18: Black Eyed Kids

    October 3rd, 2018  |  Season 1  |  1 hr 15 mins
    black eyed kids, creepypasta, paranormal, urban legend

    There's a knock at your door. You answer it and find two young children standing on your doorstep. Immediately you have an overwhelming sense of fear though you can't explain why. That is until you see their eyes... Whatever you do, don't let them in.

  • Episode 17: Elisa Lam

    September 26th, 2018  |  Season 1  |  1 hr 13 mins
    elisa lam, korean elevator game, mental illness, murder, paranormal, skid row, the cecil hotel, unsolved murder

    Bizarre behavior captured by an elevator camera leads to an even more bizarre death.

  • Episode 16: Congregation for the Light

    September 19th, 2018  |  Season 1  |  1 hr 4 mins
    atlantis, cult, karma

    You might think Manhattan's best kept secret is that swanky new underground club you and your friends can't get into. However, it might just be this modern day doomsday cult that meets weekly in a Murray Hill brownstone. Descendants of an Atlantis Aryan super race, a future without stomachs, rampant homophobia - "The Light" really ticks all the crazy boxes! And you probably wouldn't want any of them designing your home...unless you REALLY like owls.

  • 15: Slenderman

    September 12th, 2018  |  Season 1  |  1 hr 6 mins
    creepypasta, slenderman, true crime, urban legend

    Its outstretched arms will horrify you and comfort you at the same time. Is Slenderman an imaginary figment of the internet's lore, or are his powers something that reach beyond the screen?

  • Episode 14: The Dyatlov Pass Incident

    September 5th, 2018  |  Season 1  |  1 hr 15 mins
    dyatlov pass, true crime, unsolved mystery

    Nine hikers go missing on a treacherous and difficult hike up, what some call, Dead Mountain. Russian Military, aliens, bigfoot - who or what is to blame for the Dyatlov Pass incident?

  • 13: Disappearance of Ben McDaniel

    August 28th, 2018  |  Season 1  |  1 hr 21 mins
    ben mcdaniel, cave diving, true crime, unsolved mystery, vortex spring

    The deadliest diving cave in Florida, locked with a rusted gate, has claimed many lives. So what makes one man's disappearance any different? A missing body. An abandoned life. Did the depths claim Ben McDaniel or did he fake his own death to start a new life? Or, perhaps, it was something even more sinister.